A Guide to Gifting for People You Barely Know

Struggling with a Secret Santa or a gift for a new in-law? Our practical guide covers the art of finding a thoughtful, un-boring gift without being *too* personal.

You’ve drawn a name from the office Secret Santa hat, and it’s "Priya from Accounts," a person you’re 98% sure is not the same as "Priya from HR." Your partner’s cousin, who you’ve met once at a loud wedding, is having a housewarming party. Your new boss has a birthday.

Welcome to the social minefield of gifting for near-strangers.

The panic sets in. You spiral through the usual list of boring, impersonal options: a box of chocolates that says "I have no imagination," a scented candle based on pure olfactory guesswork, a generic gift card that whispers "I have given up."

This guide is your exit strategy. No toxic positivity or "it's the thought that counts" advice here. This is a practical, deadpan guide to finding a thoughtful, un-boring gift that makes you look like a creative genius, without being too personal or weird.

 

The Golden Rule: It's Not About Them, It's About You

Here's the secret: the perfect gift for someone you barely know doesn't have to reflect their personality (which is a complete mystery). It should reflect yours.

The goal is to give them a small, delightful Trojan horse for your own excellent taste and sense of humor. The gift should be a conversation starter, an object of intrigue, something that makes them think, "Huh, the person who gave me this is interesting." You're not just giving a gift; you're making a great second impression.

To do this, we've identified three archetypes of "safely quirky" gifts.

 

Archetype 1: The Shared Experience Gift

You don’t know their personal life, but you know they exist in the modern world. These gifts tap into the universal truths of work, technology, and the daily grind. The joke isn't about them; it's about the ridiculous simulation we’re all living in.

• What it looks like: A mug that perfectly captures the pain of a pointless meeting, a chart about the true priorities in life (snacks), or a to-do list for a day when the vibes are simply off.
• Why it works: You’re bonding over a shared cultural experience, not a personal one. It’s an instant "iykyk" moment with zero risk of being too forward. It says, "We're in this together."

 

Archetype 2: The Object of Intrigue

This gift’s primary purpose is to be interesting on its own terms. It doesn't need personal context because the object itself is a story. It’s a piece of art, a clever joke, or a beautiful absurdity.

• What it looks like: A mug designed to look like a museum artifact label, a crest for a secret society that doesn't exist, or a coffee cup that simply says [citation needed].
• Why it works: This gift sparks curiosity. It has its own built-in lore. It doesn't rely on an inside joke; it creates one. It's a confident move that positions you as a person of wit and mystery.

 

Archetype 3: The Interactive Experience

Instead of a static object, you give a small, fun project. This is a high-effort move that feels incredibly thoughtful without needing any personal information.

• What it looks like: A quirky jigsaw puzzle with a secret punchline, a set of illustrated coasters that first need to be assembled, or any gift that requires a little bit of fun, low-stakes effort.
• Why it works: You're not just giving a thing; you're giving a small, delightful experience. It’s an invitation to play. It feels generous and is almost universally appreciated, especially by creative or detail-oriented people.

---

Ultimately, the perfect gift for someone you barely know is one that you, yourself, would be delighted to receive. It should be a small ambassador for your own personality. Choose something that makes you laugh or think, and you'll give a gift that makes them smile and think, "I need to get to know them better."

And if you need a little help finding that ambassador, well, you're in the right place.